Feedback

The Live Wire

  • Shamik Das | Politics Summary: Tuesday, February 9th

    • 09:05
  • Time for Maya's voice to be heard amid the non-tears

    • 09:04
  • Guest | Has the left won the first round in spending cuts?

    • 09:01
  • Guido Fawkes | Apparently those MPs facing theft charges still take the Labour whip. Tories di...

    • 08:47
  • Chris Bryant | I'm definitely backing AV tonight. Every labour candidate is selected by AV and ...

    • 08:47
  • John Redwood | Why should Lib Dems vote twice?

    • 08:42
  • Mark Reckons | What difference does political blogging really make? - Event review

    • 08:42
  • Jim Knight | Great quote in Guardian: Cameron may be a pretty face; a pity that lower down he...

    • 08:39
  • Genuine regionalism could save the economy and Labour

    • 08:24
  • Dizzy | Derek Wyatt launches MyMP

    • 08:23
  • Guido Fawkes | Will Dave Really Crack Down on Lobbyists?: Yesterday Dave in his speech had a g...

  • Mark Pack | What happened to the 19 Conservative MPs who voted to keep MPs’ expenses secret?

    • 08:20
  • Guido Fawkes | Will Dave Really Crack Down on Lobbyists?

    • 08:20
  • BBC Radio 4 Today | Met police "without a doubt" still institutionally racist - Sergeant Alfred John...

    • 08:20
  • Paul Waugh | Former LibDem mayoral candidate and copper Brian Paddick says Ali Dizaei was a "...

    • 08:18
  • PPC Profile: Chris Williamson

    • 08:13
  • Hattie Garlick | Tuesday's comment from the papers in...

    • 08:07
  • Henry Macrory | Letter to Times: Do we now assume that if an MP takes a revolver into the Common...

    • 08:05
  • Morning Call: pick of the comment

    • 08:00
  • MPs ready to vote on AV referendum - 8 in the morning, February 9th

    • 08:00
  • Toby Young | Can Cameron successfully spin himself as the anti-spin candidate?

    • 07:30
  • ConservativeHome | (1) Vote Conservative... because of George Osborne

    • 07:19
  • Dizzy | Playing the race card?

    • 06:56
  • Nile Gardiner | Barack Obama faces Armageddon in latest polls

    • 04:29
  • Mike Smithson | Is it because the marginals ARE different?

    • 04:03
  • noreply@blogger.com (Working Class Tory) | Wilderness years

    • 01:11
  • Laurie Penny | Women, political blogging and the future of the left.

    • 00:44
  • Polly Curtis | Alistair Darling criticised over hidden £18bn indemnity plan

    • 00:05
  • Fiona Millar | Beware the market experiment with schools

    • 00:05
  • Steve Bell | Afghanistan death toll matches Falklands as two British soldiers die

    • 00:05
  • Poll List: Populus poll points to hung parliament

    • 23:43
  • Peter Watt | None of my friends in the pub was talking about the election tonight. The opposi...

    • 23:36
  • Stephan Shakespeare | "Should America copy Britain?" Momentum for Presidential version of PMQs http://...

  • Kerry McCarthy | Lies, damn lies and Lib Dem statistics

    • 23:28
  • Nicholas Watt | David Cameron promises two-year lobbying ban and pension penalties for former mi...

    • 23:27
  • Mark Pack | A polite round of applause directed towards The Times

    • 23:18
  • Ben Bradshaw | tories admit ashcroft doesnt pay full UK tax ie is non domiciled for tax purpose...

    • 23:15
  • Why is France selling amphibious assault ships to Russia?

    • 23:14
  • Why is France selling amphibious assault ships to Russia?

    • 23:14
  • Miliband and Jowell join forces to meet the mutual moment

    • 23:05
  • Jonathan | Why don't the Tories come clean on Lord Ashcroft's tax status?

    • 23:05
  • Iain Dale | The Daley (Half) Dozen: Monday

    • 23:05
  • Norfolk Blogger | Cameron's speech - Seeing through the spin

    • 23:05
  • Meir Javedanfar | Tehran's nuclear glue | Meir Javedanfar

    • 23:00
  • editor | Joanne Cash resigns…

    • 22:56
  • Alastair Campbell | Tories start day talking tough on sleaze. End it falling apart on Ashcroft. Big ...

    • 22:51
  • Paul Waugh | Surely @joanne_cash must have better reason than 'tensions' with local pty for q...

    • 22:47
  • baronessdeech | Schoolgirls

    • 22:16
  • Ian Katz | The case for climate action must be remade from the ground upwards | Ian Katz

    • 22:00
  • James Forsyth | The Tories think Brown is their most potent weapon

    • 21:54
  • Richard Norton-Taylor | Cabinet did not need to hear legal doubts over Iraq invasion, says Straw

    • 21:39
  • Boris Johnson | V excited about launching our groundbreaking online consultation for climate cha...

    • 21:35
  • Patrick Wintour | Labour considering paying benefit informers - Guardian

    • 21:32

Latest from The Green Box

Today's Storys

The deaths of three British soldiers in Afghanistan over the past two days brings the number of British military personnel killed there to 256 - one more than the number killed during the Falklands war.

The three major political parties clashed on the ongoing row over expenses yesterday as the Labour MPs facing criminal charges were suspended from the party and told they will only receive retirement pay-offs if they're cleared.

A new Populus poll for the Times found support for Labour up two points from last month at 30 percent, while the Conservatives were down one point at 40 percent.

According to a new report, the Treasury does not know why state-owned banks are still not lending money to small businesses.

Defence Secretary Bob Ainsworth is to face the defence select committee over the latest developments in Afghanistan and the defence green paper today.

Labour's manifesto team are considering proposals that would give people who inform on benefit cheats a share of the money saved, according to reports.

Joseph Stiglitz has urged Gordon Brown to reject "fiscal fetishism", defy the markets and maintain, or even extend, the fiscal stimulus of the British economy.

According to reports, a £20,000 compulsory inheritance levy could be introduced to pay for Labour's social care plans, but some cabinet ministers fear endorsing such a radical plan close to an election.

Ones to watch

Most voters believe Britain is "broken" and 42% of people say they would emigrate if they could, according to a new Populus poll for The Times.

The BBC is set to reveal the total amount paid to its performers who broadcast on radio and television.

The Shadow Defence Secreatry, Liam Fox accepted a £50,000 donation from a venture capitalist who helped buy a company selling defence equipment.

Britain's immigration system is not operating effectively and faces a damaging loss of public support, a report from the Parliamentary Ombudsman has warned.

The City minister Lord Myners will tell institutional investors this morning that an excessive bonus culture is hitting UK pension funds.

Tony Blair suggested the Iraq Inquiry was part of a British obsession with conspiracy, deceit and scandal.

Other stories today

Metropolitan Police Commander Ali Dizaei was yesterday sentenced to four years in jail for assaulting a man and trying to falsely accuse him in a spat over money.

Laws protecting workers' rights must be improved to tackle poverty, according to a report from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

The amount of benefits overpaid due to errors by officials has doubled from £400m to £800m since 2000, say the work and pensions select committee.

All paramilitary groups involved in the ceasefire in Northern Ireland have now decommmissioned their weapons, just 24 hours ahead of a scheduled deadline.

Harriet Harman is in line for the annual Rear of the Year award, according to The Sun.

Scottish quangos should be scrapped and replaced by independently run organisations, according to think-tank Reform Scotland.

The Archbishop of Canterbury is expected to challenge Anglican infighting over women bishops and gay ordinations at the General Synod today.

The BBC needs to "wake up" to the dearth of older females on its programmes, Harriet Harman has said.

The Commons education select committee has said the entry requirements for teacher training courses in England are too low, recommending trainee teachers have at least a 2.2.

BSkyB says it has sold a 10% stake in rival broadcaster ITV - more than half of the shares it owned.

Some 1,000 UK professionals are to be deployed around the world to rebuild countries hit by conflict or disaster.

The Conservatives have pledged to increase broadband speeds across Britain by providing BT’s rivals with regulatory incentives to introduce new telecom networks.

The Treasury will not pursue reforms to gift aid, it has been reported.

RSS Insider Research

Insider Research

Understanding the heart of Westminster

An 1832 Moment?

Panellists hope to see a reinvigorated House of Commons holding the executive to account

2009 is potentially a moment like 1832 when there could be great reform of the House of Commons.  

That's the hope of most of the PHI100.  Two thirds of them take that view against less than a third that don't.     Right-leaning, left-leaning and Lib Dem panellists agree about that.  The stand-out group are the non-aligned panellists who are the most sceptical that anything will happen to match the Great Reform Act.

One panellist says this will happen 'only if the opportunity is seized for root and branch reform.'

Another panellist would like it to happen but notes that 'parliament's ability to not reform itself is legendary.'

A third broadly agrees, saying 'the British tradition of reform is gradualist.'

A shift in power?

We asked panellists to assess whether it would be better to see more movement of powers towards external bodies or more power in a reinvigorated Commons.  

They preferred the latter by a margin of 64 to 31.    Here there was something of a political split.  Right-leaning panellists are overwhelmingly of the view that the way forward is to refresh and re-empower the Commons.   Left-leaning panellists narrowly take the opposite view.   Lib Dem panellists are split down the middle.

One panellist wants to see 'power shift to the voters'.

Another thinks there should be both more 'external oversight of MPs' conduct' and more power to MPs to 'influence the legislative process.'  

Leave a comment...

Chris
  • 17:54 |
  • 20 May 2009
  • 0

I wish I could be so optimistic as the panellists who see this an opportunity for great reform. But the idea that this centralist government is about to loosen their grip on the reins of power seems like wishful thinking.  It grieves me to say it but my vote goes to business as usual.   

As to a "power shift to the voters",  that's the last thing our politcal class wants.  The very idea would scare them rigid.